With the advent of the iPad Air 2, this will probably be my last review of iPad Air cases, although I remain surprised at the number of variations available and how many suppliers continue to ship new products late in the game (though with the Air remaining in the line-up, they can still find revenue for cases despite a smaller market for the original Air.)
Notes on Cases and Sleeves
Let me start, though, with a couple of notes on cases:
- Pleather isn’t a thing. Pleather is plastic. It feels oddly sticky, even if it looks OK at a distance. I don’t like using Pleather cases.
- If you design a sleeve, think bigger than the naked iPad, at least occasionally. Many people own cases for daily use, but want something to slip the iPad and its case into when traveling. Too many sleeves are so precisely made that they don’t work with an iPad and case, even the snuggest and most precise of cases.
- Keep the cases simple. The more pieces and parts, straps and dangles, the more to get into the way of the very clean experience expectations of iPad owners
BTW, many of the less form-fitting cases for the iPad Air will accommodate an iPad Air 2, but Apple moved the camera, so even if the case appears to fit the thinner Air 2, the camera will be covered by the case, as the lens opening opens just to metal surface of the iPad Air 2.
And Now the Case Reviews
First up will be what my iPad has been wearing for the last couple of weeks, and may well be wearing going forward, the C6 MagneFix Bookcase (Available in the UK at £40) which offers a well-fitted shell for the back of the iPad, along with a cover that also acts as a stand—a stand that is better than Apple’s competing Smart Cover. This cover and shell use magnets to firmly adhere the cover to the shell, creating a very stable platform. The cover also invokes the iPad instant-on feature. Many colors to choose from. I also like that C6 is active in environmental and social causes.
Next up is a trio of items from Brenthaven, a company that has greatly improved its offerings since its first foray into iPad cases. The latest iPad case comes in the form of the BX2™ Protector Folio for iPad Air($59.95) with a dual-layer fFoam insert and a rigid outer shell. The case meets US Department of Defense Drop Testing Standard 810G. An elastic strap holds the cover tightly when not in use (though I found it to be in the way when it was in use, though if you share this annoyance, you can easily remove the elastic band). A sticker on the back of each case provides a unique identifier that can help return lost cases to their owners (hopefully with the iPad still in tow). Overall I liked the case, but found it a bit bulky for everyday use. I never felt the cover aligned consistently when closed, which is perhaps why the designers included the elastic strap.
I also looked at two other Brenthaven cases which I really like and use regularly, they aren’t intended for the iPad. The first is the BX2 Sleeve for the MacBook Air 11 ($49.95), which almost falls into the category of being too precisely engineered. My MacBook Air, with its Moshi clear cover and 64GB near-flat USB stick permanently inserted as the home for my iTunes library, the case just barely zipped closed. Other than that, this is an outstanding sleeve, from its patent-pending Secure Grip Handle, "BX2™Xtreme Foam" four-corner drop protection, soft bubble lining and 100% Lifetime Guarantee. Why include a MacBook Air case here? Because with iPad sleeve tolerance issues, I often grab this sleeve when running out with my iPad Air. It fits well, and it leaves enough room for papers, a pen and other small items. Not what it was designed for but that is how I use it. And besides, it looks as cool, if not cooler, than many iPad-specific sleeves.
Finally in the Brenthaven line comes the Media Vertical Messenger Bag ($150), a great product for MacBook Pros and Airs. Because this case will fit up to a 13.3-inch MacBook Pro it can do double duty for the downsized: My MacBook Air 11-inch and my iPad Air (with the C6 cover or similar low-profile cover) fit inside the main compartment at the same time. And this is a good looking case, made of a soft two-tone twill exterior complemented by genuine Napa leather trim. The bag includes a padded tablet pocket (which I find too short for an Air, but fine for a iPad Mini or a smaller Kindle) and 13-inch laptop pockets. A zippered pocket on the covering flap can hold a phone. The flap uses a magnet to secure it, which makes for easy access and clean lines. An individual tracking number helps prevent loss while the 100 percent Lifetime Guarantee further covers the investment.
As an example of cases still coming into the market, German Manufacturer and distributor F&M Technology GmbH, under the name Inateck, is offering a wide variety of iPad cases and accessories as they move into the US market. Their comfy grey felt-like fiber 2 in 1 Apple ipad Mini Protective Bag(available for $18.99 in the US from Amazon) is pretty simple. Slip in the iPad Mini and connect the “super fiber leather” (as with pleather, I don’t think “super fiber leather” is a thing) strap to the magnet. Done. Well, not so done. The Inateck designers went out of the box by leveraging the case’s squishiness to make it into a bendy-wendy stand for the iPad Mini. Squeeze down the front of the case, connect the strap across the seam and now the strap becomes a restraint for the slippery iPad. Pretty clever and simple compared to some of the cases that incorporate origami to achieve similar transformations. My only negative comment on this case: even with a minimalist case on the iPad Mini, the strap isn’t long enough to reach the magnet.
Last but not least is a case I have been waiting for since the inception of the iPad Air, the ClamCase Pro for the iPad Air ($169). This case features a solid plastic outer shell (that supports waking up the iPad when opened) that essentially transforms the iPad into notebook computer without sacrificing its tablet features. Unlike a notebook computer, this case flips around backwards to that the keys are on the rear, permitting use of the tablet as a tablet. Stop half-way through the transformation and place the keys (slightly recessed to eliminate damage) on a flat surface and you have a stand. As for the keyboard: outstanding. ClamCase offers the perfect combination of layout and touch, and the brushed aluminum finish on the hand rest with the white behind the keys is just beautiful. This case make the “case” that no one should settle for inferior keyboard layouts or experiences on the iPad. Couple the design with seamless Bluetooth connection, lighter weight than previous models, and you end up with the ideal keyboard case. The only drawback: I don’t like to feel the keys when the case is folded back. It makes the tablet feel thick, awkward and I worry that I will inadvertently hit the keys in some way that will cause one to pop off.
Make the case for cases
As I keep emphasizing, cases are a big thing. European and British design shops are connecting with Chinese manufacturers for some interesting products. I’m sure the Consumer Electronic Show in Las Vegas will produce a plethora of new options for the iPad Air 2 and the iPhone 6 and 6Plus. One truth will persist in the iOS device case/sleeve market: there will always be a case to fit your mood, your attire or your use case—and it’s OK to have a case for every occasion and even one or more for unexpected situations.